Jump to Latest Follow One Handgun To Rule Them All... Glock 19x Votes: 129 76.3% Sig Sauer M17 Votes: 40 23.7% Total voters 169; 1 - 20 of 165 Posts ... Sig May drop a version of the M18 which the Compact variant the … I dunno exactly. Second Media Corp., 111 Peter Street, Suite 901, Toronto, Ontario, M5V 2H1, Canada. djquik1: 01-18-2020 06:51 PM: I’d take the M18 for several reasons. Glock 19x vs. Sig P320 I get it, comparing the Glock 19x to the Sig p320 M18, for most, is like comparing oranges grown in Florida to oranges grown in Georgia. August 30, 2018 Guest Guest Post, Guns, Pistol, Semi Automatic Pistol. Probably because of the configuration, I run a Carry P320, so that may have something to do with it. VS. Sig Sauer . Production started in 2014 with the P320, and it should be said the P320 is a series of striker pistols. Quick Reply to: ... P320 M18 . Will this be a carry gun? 19x has better sights but the M18 is cut for an optic. To put it bluntly, picture a Glock 19 slide and barrel installed on a Glock 17 grip frame. The truth is that either gun is a solid choice of do-it-all pistol. One major difference we can point out straight away is how relatively new the Sig Sauer P320 is, compared to the Glock 19. G19x. A basic Sig 229 is probably going to cost around $800 new and $650 or so used. Cost v. Handgun Updates . I know the Legion will cost twice what the M18 runs. Would appreciate pros and cons on both. Sig P320 M18 versus Glock 19X. SIG … Between the 19X and M18, I would go with the M18 all day long. The Glock is an insanely good handgun for the price (around $500), and an insanely reliable one (minus the magazine issue). Glock . Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk. Sig Sauer vs. Glock: Why the Navy SEALs Dumped the P226 for the Glock 19. This pistol sells for about $730 right now – NOT the MSRP of $832 and in time it will be even less. Of the two (M18 v 19X), I would take the Glock 19X. Although we can’t exactly tell you which pistol to choose, nor do we want to, what we can do is provide you with a comparison of the two. M18 has a very nice thumb safety if you like those. Top View: Glock 19X (Right) compared to Sig P320 X-Carry (Left). My personal preference would be the Glock but that's only due to me having more experience with them. If you want the manual safety, then it's a no brainer. vs. Beretta . I also own several 320's so I my decision is an educated one, not an emotional one. 19x is a bit smaller with lower bore axis. Do you need a 17 round full size grip and FDE gun? The MHS program resulted in the full-sized M17 handgun and the more compact M18. This is a table top review and comparison of the Sig Sauer P320 M17 and the Glock 19X. On the 2nd of January 2018, at precisely 9:00 a.m. EST, Glock announced its newest arrival the Glock 19X. So let’s be fair. Both are great guns, of course, as proven by their loyal followings, but there seems to be no real consensus on which is the best. compare . The verdict: Sig Sauer P320 vs. Glock 19. They’re both great oranges and taste great, it … Reply. Our Glock 19 barrel is compatible with Gen 3, Gen 4, and Gen 5 Glock 19 and Glock 19X. :lol: Agreed the g45 MOS would be a better comparison, other than color. Last issue with the 19x is it doesn’t have front serrations where the 45 does. In my opinion those are very equally matched pistols. At 4.99 versus 5.43 inches, the Glock 19 is .44 inches shorter than the Glock 17 and the 19X. G19x . If the frame mounted safety of the Sig is driving the train, then I would platform jump to an M&P 2.0, add some Apex trigger goodness and drive on. Glock 19 vs. Sig Sauer P320: Why I Love Them Both One of the most common questions we get asked here at GND is whether you should buy a Glock 19 or a Sig P320 . G19x. It’s small enough for CCW with either grip module too. Value is subjective. Its the only glock of this size frame with that issue, any other 17/19/34 from any gen can interchange mags. I’ve got both. They competed for the MHS contract against each other. When using a Gen 5 magazine with the extended base plate, the front of the base plate hits the lip.. M18 has a very nice thumb safety if you like those. The report had nothing but great things to say about this Sig. It’s a superb pistol. and if the color and Gen5 mag comparability issues bother you on the 19x just get a 45. I love my GLOCK, more than any other pistol. Both are great guns, of course, as proven by their loyal followings, but there seems to be no real consensus on which is the best. Between those two, would likely go with the 19X because I like shorter barrels. P320 M17. The Glock 19X Compared To The Glock 19 Gen 5 The Glock 19X Compared To The Glock 19 Gen 5. It just works! 142 Posts #21 • 12 mo ago. Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G19x and Sig Sauer P320 M17. I ever so slightly preferred the G-19X. Glock 19 vs. Sig Sauer P320: Why I Love Them Both One of the most common questions we get asked here at GND is whether you should buy a Glock 19 or a Sig P320 . Introduced to the market in January, the Glock 19X is now marketed as something of a “do all” handgun, blending a full-sized frame with a mid-sized slide and the company’s Generation 5 features. https://www.handgunhero.com/compare/glock-g19x-vs-sig-sauer-p320-m18 Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Contribute; Contact; Glock . M18 has a better trigger and replaceable grip frames (though replacement frames for the safety are a bit harder to come by). If you want the manual safety, then it's a no brainer. I would appreciate pros and cons on both. Glock 19x vs. Sig P320 I get it, comparing the Glock 19x to the Sig p320 M18, for most, is like comparing oranges grown in Florida to oranges grown in Georgia. The M-18 can be used like the 1911, cocked and locked, which has considerable appeal. Both are accurate and reliable. I haven't been interested in purchasing a Glock in a very long time. P320 M17. Better ergonomics. However . However, with the selection of the SIG P320 as the M17 and M18 Modular Handgun System, many individuals in the industry have been compelled to cry foul and demand the Army retry the competition between the two finalists, Glock and SIG. I can easily find parts, holsters, and other accessories for it anywhere I go. Sig Sauer Inc. just released the civilian version of the U.S. Army's M18, the compact pistol that may be the most popular of the Modular Handgun System line. Not sure what that means, but the G45 is a fantastic firearm. After 13 years of searching for the US Army’s next pistol, a successor to the Beretta M9 has been selected. Please Wait. I handled both the Glock 19X and the SIG M17 at the same time while attempting to choose one of the two. The Army selected Sig in … But I've always been a real fan of slim, single-stack 9's. For a better experience, please enable JavaScript in your browser before proceeding. For me, I would take the Glock, but it's only because I prefer the Glock. You can’t find a more widely used pistol than the GLOCK 19. Since I now run a red dot on everything the 18 has the advantage of that standard versus the 19x, but the 45 can be had in MOS as a better alternative. I have a G45 (G19X but black) that I have had for a year and close to 3000 rounds through. Next the 19x is not an MOS gun from the factory, the G45 MOS & Sig M18 are both optics ready. Sig Sauer M17 vs Glock 19x / 45. This is because the 19X grip has a lip that extends down and in front of the magazine. 19x has better sights but the M18 is … Perhaps most importantly, price is always a factor when it … APX . Con: they are both brown - multiple shades of brown. APX . According to the report, Glock submitted one full-sized handgun (presumably the G17 or G19) and Sig submitted two, a full-sized and compact version of the P320. Handgun Updates . The Sig Sauer P320. The GLOCK 19X is a very solid, supremely reliable, and accurate gun that’s somewhat unique on the market today. If the frame mounted safety of the Sig is driving the train, then I would platform jump to an M&P 2.0, add some Apex trigger goodness and drive on. Registered FFL Certified Glock Armorer Certified P320 Armorer LE&NRA Firearms Instructor They’re both great oranges and taste great, it … compare . G19x . After much thinking I had pretty well decided to go with the Sig P320 M18. SIG 320 barrel compatibility: Our barrels have been proven to work with these 320 models only: P320 Full Size: P320 RX Full-Size P320 Nitron Full-Size. However, with the selection of the SIG P320 as the M17 and M18 Modular Handgun System, many individuals in the industry have been compelled to cry foul and demand the Army retry the competition between the two finalists, Glock and SIG. Given the crucible of law enforcement use for over a quarter-century, and given FIVE generations of constant improvement, NO HANDGUN can go toe-to-toe against Glock. The overall length of both is right at 7 inches, while the width of each also match closely, with the Glock measuring 1.26 inches compared to 1.3 inches of the SIG. The GAO said each was very close in performance and other factors that evaluators looked into, Sig came in with a program price nearly $130 million less than Glock. I know comparing the M18 to the SAO Legion is like comparing apples to oranges however would appreciate thoughts on this Legion model. VS. Sig Sauer . The G45 is about the only Glock I have a desire to purchase. The G19X is also a Gen5 design, so it is the latest model. I'll take the more natural aiming Sig. TXPO . JavaScript is disabled. The Sig 229 is a gorgeous piece of mechanical engineering. So far I'm really liking it. In fact, the full-sized Sig is more like the larger Glock 17, and the Subcompact model is more fairly compared to Glock’s offering in that area, the Glock 26. I am looking at purchasing either a Sig P320 M18 or a Glock 19x. It’s all about practicality. compare . Both are accurate and reliable. Glock . We do a general spec comparison. compare . The Glock is easier to maintain in the field and spare parts are cheap, plentiful and easy to to use. The Pro for the 19X: ubiquitous The con for the 19X: With Glock Gen 5 magazines, the extended base plate will not fit the Glock 19X. This isn’t exactly a fair competition, not because one gun is better than the other, but this … I just sold my Glock 45, which is a Black 19X basically. Really like grip and the excellent thumb safety of M-18. The Glock has far more support in the market re holsters, mag pouches, magazines etc. Shoot them and pick the one you shoot/like better. A lot of people wonder which gun is the worthier purchase, so pondering the Sig P320 vs. Glock 19 is certainly a good thing. If not, I'd look at the P320 X-compact or the standard 19 for EDC. Likely because of muscle memory of my G-22 and G-24 and G-35. Modularity is one of them. To be fair, the G19X is sized closer to the compact version of the military P320 which is the M18, but since SIG AIR only has the Glock 17-sized M17, I decided I would run the G19X against it for style and performance. I’d also choose a P320 M17 if that means anything to you. At 7.36 versus 8.03 inches, the Glock 19 and 19X slides are .67 inches shorter than the Glock 17’s. … Striker-Fired Compact Pistol . My affinity for these handguns isn’t down to their looks or feel. The Glock has far more support in the market re holsters, mag pouches, magazines etc. Our pistols include the Beretta APX, CZ P-09 Suppressor-Ready, Glock 19X, Sig Sauer P320-M17 and Smith & Wesson M&P9 M2.0. Sig P320 M18 versus Glock 19x . A forum community dedicated to SIG Sauer Pistols and SIG Sauer Rifles owners and enthusiasts. Handgun Search; Tabletop Compare; Contribute; Contact; Glock . vs. Beretta . Is Glock 19 a bit smaller and easier to find Holsters for? Very easy to shoot fast as well. Moreover, Sig offered a two-gun proposal — the XM17 and compact XM18 — to Glock’s single-gun bid. I could definitely see myself buying a G48 Black when "Glock Days" rolls around this summer. For three decades, the U.S. Navy’s Sea Air Land (SEAL) special-forces teams relied on a … Come join the discussion about optics, hunting, gunsmithing, styles, reviews, accessories, classifieds, and more! But have decided to wait and hope they do a .40S&W "X"-model. Hopefully, after reading this you’ll have a clearer picture of which one is right for you. Glock's "safe action" has been kicking ass and taking names since the 1980's. The Glock is easier to maintain in the field and spare parts are cheap, plentiful and easy to to use. 19x is a bit smaller with lower bore axis. Compare the dimensions and specs of Glock G19x and Sig Sauer P320 M17. I picked up an M18 a bit over a week ago and have 400 rounds through it. For me that would be the 48 Black. Slap a P320 carry grip module on and you have a fancy M18. P320 Compact: P320 RX … Striker-Fired Compact Pistol . The Glock 19 will certainly be easier to come by, and offers more aftermarket parts than the Sig. The Glock 19 weighs a little bit more, but it also has a slightly longer barrel and slide. A G45 MOS would be almost identical to the M18 with the exception of the safety on the Sig as mentioned before. When my M17 gets here, I'll give you my opinion on the two. A Glock costs about $80 to produce and a Sig costs about $300 to produce, so clearly higher production cost is a higher cost. Sig Sauer M17 vs Glock 19x / 45. Unlike the M17 and M18. Both are accurate & reliable. You almost can’t go wrong with it. Something about the less slide mass, and the longer grip giving more control. Accuracy. Pretty much the rest is above. Where, if you drop it or bump the butt of the gun, it fires. I own both and they are both great choices. One minor point if you buy a lot of magazines (I do) the glock ones are way cheaper. Choose the one that handles the most naturally to you. ... P320 M18 . I hate the Glock grip angle so it is an easy choice for me. Today I was perusing the net and read a report on the Sig P226 SAO Legion. I am currently looking at these two pistols for EDC and range use. A Glock 19 can cost as little as $525 new with two mags. M18 has a better trigger and replaceable grip frames (though replacement frames for the safety are a bit harder to come by).